Home » Best Sleeping Pills Over The Counter [Nutritional Values & Reviews]

Best Sleeping Pills Over The Counter [Nutritional Values & Reviews]

best sleeping pills over the counter

Trying hard to just get a good night’s sleep? We’ve rounded up some of the best over the counter sleeping pills based on their nutritional values, neuroscience and consumer reports. That includes top rated OTC sleep aid to help you get deep sleep and reduce your daily stress. 

These non-prescription sleep aids are formulated to help people like you who have sleep problems overnight get restful sleep. 

Here is the list of what you’ll find on this page. Click the link below to go straight to a specific section.

Table of Content

Disclosure: A few of the links on this blog are affiliate links. It means, at no additional cost, we will get a little commission if you click through and purchase.

The Best Natural OTC Sleep Aid

VitaPost Sleep Support Plus

It is one of the best OTC sleep aid on the market. 

Their vegan capsules are formulated with minerals, vitamins, and other active ingredients to help you get good night's sleep.

Here are just a few of the ingredients in these natural sleeping pills.

  • Tryptophan
  • Melatonin - It is a hormone that helps reduce occasional sleeplessness and jet lag. It improves the natural sleep cycle and quality of rest.
  • Goji berry
  • Lemon balm
  • Chamomile
  • Valerian

VitaPost Sleep Support Plus is produced in the U.S. with FDA registered facilities that comply with GMP requirements. 

If you're looking for a non-prescription and vegan friendly sleeping aid, Sleep Support Plus can be a right choice to go for.

Learn More

Best Non-habit-forming Sleeping pill


GNC PREVENTIVE NUTRITION® TRI-SLEEP™ is a non-habit coated oral medicinal tablet (caplets).

It is a scientifically formulated triple-layer sleep aid that:

  • Promotes relaxation
  • Helps you go to sleep faster
  • supports calm sleep

Here are some of the ingredients in TRI-SLEEP™.


  • L-theanine - It supports relaxation with no drowsiness
  • Saffron extract
  • Valerian root extract - Valerian is a herb that people commonly use it for sleep disorders such as insomnia because of its sedative effects.
  • Melatonin

GABA - People use it because its calming effect on the brain. It is used in sleep medicines to reduce stress.

best non-habit-forming sleeping pills over the counter

strongest over the counter sleep aid

Natrol Melatonin Advanced OTC sleeping pills

Each tablet contains 10 mg of melatonin, which makes it one of the strongest sleeping pills. Plus, it gives 10 mg of vitamin b6 and 23 mg of calcium.

This product helps you not only fall asleep faster but also stay asleep longer. 

Also, its advanced formula promotes better sleep by 2-layer controlled melatonin time release. as well, it helps to reduce occasional sleeplessness. 

Plus, natrol is drug-free, and users reported that tablets are easy to swallow. 

strong over the counter sleeping tablets

Nature's Bounty Sleep3

This product is of maximum strength and drug-free sleep aid. Each tablet gives 10 mg of melatonin to help you fall asleep faster and stay asleep by reducing casual sleep deprivation.

Also, it contains 100 mg of GABA and 60g of Ashwagandha to reduce occasional stress.

Plus, this product has a triple action time-release technology to help you:

  • Fall asleep fast
  • Stay asleep longer 
  • Relax and destress
  • Wake up feeling refreshed

maximum strength otc sleeping pills

REMfresh Extra Strength

If you need extra sleep, Extra Strength REMfresh is an excellent over the counter sleep medication. 

It gives 5 mg of advanced ion-powered melatonin that releases continuous release to provide a deep and restful sleep for up to 7 hours.

So, this product can help to:

  • Fall asleep faster
  • Stay asleep longer
  • Improve sleep quality
  • Wake up refreshed

Extra Strength REMfresh OTC sleeping pills

Best Pain Reliever And Sleep Aid Pills

Tylenol PM Extra Strength

Tylenol PM Extra Strength is a nighttime pain medication and OTC sleeping pills that contains acetaminophen.

It can help to ease minor pains while assisting fall asleep. It is another non-habit forming sleeping pill if you relieve minor aches and pains while helping you fall asleep and is non-habit forming when used as directed.

Tylenol PM each caplet has active ingredients such as acetaminophen and diphenhydramine.

It is formulated to relieve minor aches such as occasional headaches coupled with sleeplessness. Want to say, Tylenol PM is a pain reliever that can help fall asleep and stay asleep. For that reason you have to take it at night only (right before bedtime).

Tylenol PM extra strength pain reliever & sleep aid caplets

ValuMeds PM Pain Reliever and Nighttime OTC sleeping pills

Each blue caplet contains 500mg of acetaminophen to reduce minor aches. Such as headache, muscle, joint, and arthritis pain fast.

Also, this PM product gives 25mg of diphenhydramine HCl to help you fall asleep and relax.

Plus, caplets are small in size and non-habit forming. Plus, it claims to be gentle on your stomach.

pm pain reliever and nighttime sleep aid with acetaminophen

Best Doxylamine Succinate Tablets

Unisom SleepTabs

Unisom SleepTabs is famous for over-the-counter sleeping pills that claim to help you fall asleep 33% faster.

Each blue over the counter sedative tablet contains 25 mg of doxylamine succinate. Plus, it is non-habit forming and helps get quality sleep and wake up restored.

Also, most users say that SleepTabs are easy to swallow and good value for money.

best doxylamine succinate sleeping pills over the counter

kirkland sleep aid

Each sleeping tablets gives 25 mg of doxylamine succinate. Which is an antihistamine. 

This product is easy to swallow and helps with difficulty in falling asleep. It blocks histamine and acetylcholine that makes you sleepy so that you will fall asleep fast.

Plus, Kirkland Signature Sleep Aid helps reduce occasional sleeplessness. As well, It is non-habit forming and acts fast. 


Best Diphenhydramine

ValuMeds Nighttime Sleep Aid

Each blue softgel gives 50 mg of diphenhydramine HCl that makes it one of the best OTC sleep meds.

This product claims help you get to sleep quickly and wake up refreshed.

blue sleeping pills with diphenhydramine

Unisom Sleep Gels

Unisom non-prescription sleeping pills help you fall asleep 33% faster.

Each softgel contains 50 mg of diphenhydramine hcl to maximize night sleep and wake up energized.

blue softgels OTC sleep aid

Best Melatonin Sleeping Pills

Carlyle melatonin pills

Each Fast Dissolve Tablet contains 12 mg of melatonin.

This product helps reduce occasional sleeplessness caused by jet lags. Also, it is drug-free and helps you get better rest.

best melatonin sleeping pills

Best Valerian

NOW Supplements, Valerian Root

Each capsule gives 500 mg of valerian root extract.

best valerian root pills

Best Gummy

ZzzQuil Pure Zzzs

Zzzquil gives 2 mg of melatonin. Plus, it contains lavender, valerian root, and chamomile to regulate your sleep.

Also, it helps fall asleep faster, plus not wake up the next day with grogginess.

ZzzQuil Pure Zzzs OTC sleeping gummy

Best For Anxiety


NEUBRIA™ DRIFT SLEEP by Natural Botanicals is one of top 10 sleeping pills over the counter. Each vegan sleeping capsule is made of scientifically researched ingredients such as,

  • Melatonin
  • GABA
  • Magnesium

Drift is formulated with a super natural relaxation-promoting herbs to support relaxation and tranquility, like,

  • Passion flower - It is a climbing vine that is used for anxiety, including anxiety before surgery. Also people find it effective for reducing insomnia and stress.
  • Hops - A study on the effects of hops shows that daily supplementation with hops can reduce symptoms of mild depression, stress, and anxiety.
  • Valerian - This herb is most commonly used for sleep disorders especially insomnia. It can also reduce anxiety and stress.
  • Chamomile -Since ancient times, chamomile because of its sedative effects has been used to treat insomnia as a mild tranquilizer and sleep-inducer.
  • Melissa (lemon balm) - This herb helps to relieve stress, reduce anxiety, improve mood and boosts cognitive function. It is also used to alleviate sleep troubles like insomnia.
  •  Wild jujube extracts

Consumer reviews on GNC show that it can help get a full night of sleep and wake up quite refreshed and energetic. It can help you fall asleep and stay asleep more time. 

So, Drift can be taken into account as one of the best over the counter sedative.


Best Sleeping Pills For Kids

Zarbee's Naturals Children's Sleep with Melatonin

best sleeping pills for kids

Natrol Melatonin Kid Gummies

Natrol Melatonin Kid Gummies

Best For Insomnia

Sleep Fairy Natural Sleep Aid | Anxiety & Insomnia Relief Supplement

best sleeping pills for insomnia